Thursday, January 30, 2014

Olympia by Manet

Titian. Venus of Urbino. 1538. Oil Paint. Uffizi Gallery, Florence, Italy.
      As a class, we analyzed two paintings that were very similar to each other yet had their differences. Both paintings invlolved a naked woman lying on a bed covering one of her parts with the left hand. One of the paintings we took a look at was Venus of Urbino by Titian. We used different techniques such as, observing objects, noticing our feelings, noticing our focal points and making conclusions. Many conclusions can be brought up regarding this painting. One being that people in power can be indifferent to bad things going on.
      Our eyes from this painting can go on to view three main things, the naked lady on the bed, the two women in the back or the background which gives us a little view of the house which they are in. My attention was brought to the colors being used, wine red grabs our attention. This color is usually present in royalty and wealth. The background where we can see what seems to be a hallway, looks like the house where they are isn't just an ordinary house but where important people live. In order for you to be lying naked comfortably, you must be in a place where you feel welcomed, in a place you know and you are comfortable in. This is one of the reasons we can think that the lady in the forefront is powerful. He posture seems very relaxed, and she holds either rose petals or grapes, another symbol of wealth. She also wears a headband that makes her look more like a goddess and a bracelet. The way she is, is also the way the puppy is. They're both resting as if with no care in the world, even if there's a scene behind them. Her face seems pleasant and has a smirk, some sort of seducing look it seems. Her naked body shows she doesn't care if she's not covered, just like the powerful may not care of the situations going around them.
      The scene behind the powerful woman is of two other woman who are covered from shoulders to feet. One of the women is on her knees while the other is watching over her, standing beside her. The one on her knees isn't very visible, all we are able to see is the back of her body but we cannot take a look at her facial expression or what her arms are doing. The colors in the back are darker than where the naked lady lays. The lady standing is rolling up her sleeves which all of these visuals give us a clue that perhaps the lady on her knees is getting punished or the lady standing is about to help her. Maybe the "goddess" did harm to the woman on her knees. Whatever the case may be, the powerful woman is not looking back.
       The woman in the front may not be aware of what's going on or simply doesn't care. She looks at us with a relaxed face, no sign of her getting up or looking behind her. Symbolically, the gazing away from the tense scene behind her represents the privilege she holds, of being able to be ignorant to the problems and troubles others may have nearby.

1 comment:

  1. Natalie, you provide rich descriptions and details that support your thesis about the lady in focus being powerful/wealthy and indifferent to what is going on behind her. You provide different types of visual details: the facial expression of the woman, symbols of wealth like the color red or the flowers, and the woman's posture. The structure of this analysis is clear with a beginning/explanation, details, and a conclusion. Super work!
    (p.s. one grammatical issue for you is that you often use a comma where a colon would work better. Use a colon if you are going to list a bunch of examples like I modeled in this response. You could have used a colon after "three main things" in the above essay.

    ReplyDelete